NEW! Lucibello’s Venetian Table Kit

Original price was: $224.99.Current price is: $209.99. - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Make your very own Venetian Table at home with these delicious items from New Haven's famous Lucibello's Pastry Shop. Each Table Kit includes:
  • 1 Pound of Anginette Cookies
  • 2 Pounds of Assorted Italian Cookies
  • 1 Pound Pinole Cookies
  • 1 6 Piece Sicilian Cannoli Kit
  • Your Choice 6 pcs of either: Sfogliatella, Almond Tarts, Ricotta Pasticiotti/Bocconitti, Rum Babas (PICK ONE AND PLEASE ENTER IN ORDER NOTES)
  • Your Choice of either: 4 Pcs. Vanilla, Chocolate or Mixed Napoleon Cannoli or 12 Pcs Vanilla, Chocolate or Mixed Mini Pasticiotti/Bocconitti (PICK ONE AND PLEASE ENTER IN ORDER NOTES)
Again, please put your selections in the Order Notes field. NOTE: If you do not select specific items, we will send you 6 Sfogliatella and 4pcs Assorted Vanilla & Chocolate Napoleon Cannoli. Sorry, no substitutions.

NEW! Make Your Own Charcuterie/Antipasto Kit

Original price was: $105.99.Current price is: $101.99. - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Be a hit at your party or anyone else's with this delicious Make Your Own Charcuterie/Antipasto Kit! Perfect for yourself or a Gift! This Kit Includes Everything You Need- Just Start Slicing!
  • Your Choice of Alp's Hot or Sweet Sopressata from Napoli Foods (PLEASE INDICATE PREFERENCE IN THE NOTES)
  • Your Choice of Citterio Calabrese (Hot) or Abruzze (Mild) Salami from Napoli Foods (PLEASE INDICATE PREFERENCE IN THE NOTES)
  • Approx 1/2 lb wedge of Drunken Goat Cheese from Liuzzi Cheese
  • Approx 1.2 lb ball of Burrini Cheese from Liuzzi Cheese
  • 12 oz. Jar Marinated Eggplant from Napoli Foods
  • 14 oz. Jar  Marinated Mushrooms from Napoli Foods
  • 12.5 oz Jar Pitted Kalamata Olives from Napoli Foods
  • 14 oz. Jar Hot Stuffed Peppers from Napoli Foods
  • 7 oz. Bag Freselle from Apicella's
Note: If you do not indicate a preference for Hot or Sweet, we will send Sweet Sopressata and Abruzze Salami. Sorry, no substitutions.
Photo Credit ID 207167892 | Charcuterie Board © Pamela Mcadams | Dreamstime.com

NEW! Oktoberfest All Year Sampler

Original price was: $55.99.Current price is: $51.99. - or subscribe and save up to 5%
It doesn't have to be October to enjoy these fine traditional meats from New Haven's famous Hummel Bros. This sampler comes with 3 pounds of Hummels Knockwurst and 3 pounds of Hummels Bratwurst plus a 2 lb pouch of Napoli Sauerkraut to enjoy any time of year. Easy and convenient.

NEW! Petonito’s Rainbow Chocolate Covered Pignoli Cookies (3 Cookies)

$44.99 - or subscribe and save up to 5%
A fantastically delicious mash-up from Petonito's Bakery combining several delicious flavors into one great taste. Pignoli Cookies made with classic rainbow cookie colors and half dipped in chocolate = HEAVEN! These are 3 large cookies (approximately 3-4" diameter each) and the total weight is about 3/4 of a pound! Try them and we think you'll love them- we do!

NEW! Petonito’s Rainbow Cookie Cake – 2 Pcs

$21.99 - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Rainbow cookies are a belived Italian treat, with its colorful bands and wonderful taste. Petonito's Bakery has taken them to the next level by making that same recipe into a cake. This is the same as a rainbow cookie, but in an approximately 4" x 4" square of cake. A delicious and festive treat!  You Get 2 Squares of Cake Per Order!

NEW! Spice of Life Meat & More Sampler

Original price was: $135.99.Current price is: $129.99. - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Like your food a little spicy? Well we've curated some great selections that will dazzle your taste buds with this spicy sampler! Includes:
  • 3 lbs Lamberti's Hot Sausage Links
  • 1 8 oz stick Margherita Pepperoni from Napoli Foods
  • 1 16 oz Alp's Hot Sopressata from Napoli Foods
  • 1 3lb package of Hummel's Red Hots
  • 1 14 oz jar of Napoli Hot Stuffed Cherry Peppers stuffed with Prosciutto and Cheese
  • 1 8 oz jar of Napoli Hot Stuffed Cherry Peppers stuffed with Breadcrumbs and Anchovy
  • 2 12 oz jars of Blackies Hot Pepper Relish
All in one easy package!

NEW! Spice of Life Meat Sampler

Original price was: $92.99.Current price is: $86.99. - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Like your meats a little spicy? Well we've curated some great selections that will dazzle your taste buds with this spicy sampler! Includes:
  • 3 lbs Lamberti's Hot Sausage Links
  • 1 8 oz stick Margherita Pepperoni from Napoli Foods
  • 1 16 oz Alp's Hot Sopressata from Napoli Foods
  • 1 3lb package of Hummel's Red Hots
All in one easy package!

Petonito’s 10″ Cannoli Pie

$38.99 - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Petonito's Pastry Shop in East Haven is also well known for its Cannoli Pie. We're proud to offer this combination of delicious and sweet cannoli filling with chocolate chips, baked into a sweet, flaky crust and topped with powdered sugar, chocolate and chocolate chips, to our customers. Think of a larger pie version of a Sicilian Cannoli. Yum! Note: Our pies come double boxed for protection. Don't try and lift the inner box out of the outer box or you may crush the pie. Instead, cut the string and open the inner box, then remove the pie. Thanks!

Petonito’s 10″ Chocolate Lemon Pie

$38.99 - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Petonito's Pastry Shop in East Haven has always had a wonderful Chocolate Lemon Pie on its menu. We're proud to offer this fudgy, lemony goodness to our customers in a flaky, sweet crust. These two flavors go wonderfully together and make a great dessert or coffee accompaniment. Note: Our pies come double boxed for protection. Don't try and lift the inner box out of the outer box or you may crush the pie. Instead, cut the string and open the inner box, then remove the pie. Thanks!

Petonito’s 10″ Italian Cream Pie

$38.99 - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Petonito's Pastry Shop in East Haven is well known for its Italian Cream Pie. We're proud to offer this combination of half vanilla and half chocolate Italian Cream, baked into a sweet, flaky crust and topped with powdered sugar, to our customers. Think of a larger pie version of a Pasticiotti/Bocconotti. Yum! Note: Italian cream pies are heavy and typically in shipping the top crust may crack. We want you to be aware of this as it is a result of the shipping process and not damage. Our pies come double boxed for protection. Don't try and lift the inner box out of the outer box or you may crush the pie. Instead, cut the string and open the inner box, then remove the pie.

Petonito’s Chocolate and Vanilla Italian Cream Cupcakes- 6pcs. 3 of each

$36.99 - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Petonito's Pastry Shop in East Haven is well known for its creative cupcakes and these Vanilla and Chocolate Cupcakes are filled with delicious vanilla and chocolate Italian cream and topped with multi colored sprinkles- 6pcs. A must have treat! 3 of each Cupcake flavor.

Petonito’s Chocolate Cannoli Cupcakes- 6pcs.

$36.99 - or subscribe and save up to 5%
Petonito's Pastry Shop in East Haven is well known for its creative cupcakes and these Cannoli Cupcakes are the perfect mix of tradition and modern convenience. Delicious Cannoli filling with chocolate chips, filled inside of  Chocolate Petonito's Cupcakes- 6pcs.Cupcakes make this a must have treat! 6 pcs.